Lack of science, legal authority and costs are raised with other substantial concerns 

MEDIA CONTACT:
For media inquiries, contact media@sugar.org.

WASHINGTON, D.C., August 1, 2014 – The Sugar Association (SA) filed comments today in response to Food and Drug Administration (FDA) Proposed Rule, Food Labeling: Revision of the Nutrition and Supplement Facts Labels. SA is calling on FDA to withdraw its “added sugars” labeling proposal, noting that it represents a reversal of FDA’s long-standing science-based position on labeling.

In its comments, SA expresses concern about the use of the misleading term “added sugars” and that the lack of science to justify “added sugars” labeling sets an alarming precedent for this and future food product labeling regulations.

The Association raised serious concerns about the contradiction between the science cited to support “added sugars” labeling and the Agency’s assertion in the Proposed Rule that, “We generally consider scientific evidence to be ‘well established’ when such consensus reportshave determined the evidence to be ‘conclusive,’ ‘documented,’ or ‘strong’.”

“General dietary guidance in the 2010 Dietary Guidelines to increase or reduce certain components of the diet has merit for the general population. However, we have serious concerns that it is a gross expansion of the intent of the law governing the Dietary Guidelines for Americans to use selective dietary guidance from a single edition of the DGA as the primary basis to promulgate food labeling regulations,” the comments state.

SA points out that a thorough examination of the National Evidence Library scientific evidence reviews, which the 2010 DGAC used to support their “added sugars” guidance, confirms that no “conclusive” “documented” or “strong” evidence was cited in support of the assertion that “added sugars” contributes to weight gain, nutrient displacement, displacement of nutrient-rich foods, obesity and heart disease.   

SA notes that no authoritative scientific body has found a public health need to set an upper level (UL) for “added sugars” intake, including the Institute of Medicine in 2002 and the European Food Safety Authority in 2010, which was confirmed by FDA in the Proposed Rule. 

The Association expressed a number of additional concerns with the proposed “added sugars” labeling, outlined below:

SA also notes that there are legitimate questions as to whether FDA has the legal authority to exponentially expand its authority to require recordkeeping and inspection of these proprietary records. 

“In keeping with the President’s Executive Order 13563, new product labeling regulations should be based solely on the best available science and considerable deference should be given to the fact that implementation of this regulation would be excessively burdensome and costly for the entire food industry and ultimately the consuming public,” the comments conclude.

More Press Releases

Sugar Industry Celebrates Through Giving this National Real Sugar Day

October 12, 2023

Highlighting real people, real plants, and real community impact WASHINGTON, D.C. – On Saturday, October 14, the Sugar Association (SAI), along with the organization’s 15 members, will celebrate the people and the plants that make real sugar possible on the second annual National Real Sugar Day. Alongside its member companies, the Sugar Association founded National Real Sugar Day as […]

sugar-association logo

New Research Shows Consumers are Looking for Facts on Real Sugar

June 21, 2023

Closing the “sugar information gap” empowers consumers to achieve Real Sugar balance WASHINGTON, D.C. – Today, the Sugar Association released research findings from a consumer survey demonstrating consumers remain interested in knowing where real sugar comes from and how much of it they can eat. “This survey confirms a growing trend of consumers are looking […]

sugar-association logo

Statement by the Sugar Association: USDA/International Dairy Foods Association Healthy School Milk Commitment

April 5, 2023

The Sugar Association (SAI) and its members are committed to helping Americans, including school aged children, achieve a balanced diet and healthy lifestyle through consuming all nutrients – including sugar – in the right amounts.

More Press Releases

Stay in Touch

Sign Up