Proposal Compromises Agency’s Well‐Established Science-Based Principles

October 14, 2015, Washington, DC —The Sugar Association is raising serious concerns about the Food and Drug Administration’s (FDA) proposal to require an “added sugars” declaration and daily reference value (DRV) on the Nutrition Facts Label (NFL).

“FDA has not provided the scientific evidence to uphold its own statutory requirement that ‘added sugars’ labeling and a DRV for ‘added sugars’ is ‘necessary to assist consumers in maintaining healthy dietary practices,’” The Sugar Association stated in its comment provided to FDA this week.

The Sugar Association notes that in this rulemaking effort, FDA has openly admitted it has deviated from “factors traditionally considered for mandatory declaration” of nutrients on the NFL. The record shows that FDA has arbitrarily selected from general dietary guidance, science of low evidentiary value and unofficial, controversial reports like the 2015 Dietary Guidelines Advisory Committee (DGAC) Report to support its proposal for “added sugars” labeling and to set a DRV.

In addition, FDA’s own consumer research shows that should the Agency move forward with its “added sugars” labeling proposal it will mislead and confuse consumers.

The extraordinary contradictions and irregularities in this rulemaking process coupled with the use of scientific evidence of extremely low evidentiary value to propose “added sugars” labeling and a DRV is unprecedented for the FDA.

The Sugar Association points to the following specific concerns with the quality of scientific evidence and the irregularities in this rulemaking process used by the Agency to support its proposal:

“FDA has not provided evidence that, under section 403(q)(2)(A) of the Act, there is
sufficient scientific evidence of a compelling public health reason to modify the current ‘Sugars’ category to include ‘added sugars’ labeling and a set DRV for ‘added sugars.’ To reiterate, the Agency has not provided evidence that ‘added sugars’ labeling is necessary ‘to assist consumers in maintaining healthy dietary practices,’” The Sugar Association states.

“For the reasons outlined above, we ask FDA to withdraw its proposals to include ‘added sugars’ on the NFL and to set a DRV for ‘added sugars.’ Should FDA believe that ‘added sugars’ labeling is important, the Agency should follow its standard of sufficient scientific agreement and ask the Institute of Medicine to do a thorough review of the full body of scientific evidence (at the highest level of evidence available) on ‘added sugars’ intake,” The Sugar Association concludes.

To view The Sugar Association’s submitted comments in their entirety, click here.

More Press Releases

sugar-association logo

National campaign empowers consumers to achieve added sugars goals and build balanced diets

June 13, 2024

June 13, 2024 (Washington, DC) – To support Americans in understanding and achieving the Dietary Guidelines for Americans’ recommendation for limiting added sugars to no more than 10% of total calories, the Sugar Association is expanding its nation-wide consumer education campaign, alongside resources for registered dietitians, with the theme “Life is sweet, keep it balanced.” […]

sugar-association logo

USDA school meals rule could decrease diet quality, expose kids to more artificial sweeteners

April 24, 2024

April 24, 2024 (Washington, DC) – While welcoming the alignment of school meals with the Dietary Guidelines for Americans (DGA) and supporting the aim to limit added sugars to 10% of each week’s menu, the Sugar Association today (Wednesday) cautioned that imposing added sugars limits on individual products could limit access to nutrient-dense foods that […]

sugar-association logo

New WIC rule could decrease diet quality, further increase use of artificial sweeteners

April 9, 2024

April 9, 2024 (Washington, DC) – While welcoming the dietary balance and flexibility reflected in the new Special Supplemental Nutrition Program for Women, Infants and Children (WIC) rule announced today (Tuesday), the Sugar Association cautioned that added sugars limited on individual products could limit access to nutrient-dense foods that are associated with better overall diet […]

More Press Releases

Stay in Touch

Sign Up